This image was lent to me by
DrBechara Y. Ghorayeb,
anotolaryngologist in Houston, TX. You can see other
images of tongue cancer on his site by clicking
here.
If you have come here to look for
images of lumps, bumps, sores, discolorations or abnormalities that you noticed in the
mirror this morning, this is one of four pages with images you may find
useful. Read this page,
Then proceed to three other pages on which you will find more images
of both normal and abnormal oral structures and lesions
Oral Cancer--The facts (and why that lump you
noticed in the mirror this morning is probably NOT cancer!)
Oral and pharyngeal (throat) cancer represents about 3%
to 5% of all forms of cancer. Each year, more than 30,000 new cases of
cancer of the oral cavity and pharynx are diagnosed and over 8,000
deaths due to oral cancer occur. If
cancer of the larynx, which is quite similar to oral squamous cell cancer and
has similar risk factors is included, an additional 14,000 diagnoses are added to
the total. Approximately one person dies from oral cancer every
hour around the clock in the US.
The five year survival rate for
this type of cancer has remained at about 50% since the early 1960's.
About half of the cases occur in persons over the age of 65. 95%
of all cases occur in persons over the age of 40. An increasing percentage
is diagnosed in persons under the age of 40, although the incidence of oral
cancer in younger persons is still very low by comparison.
Oral cancer attacks
more men than women (male/female ratio = 2/1), and more blacks than whites
(black/white ratio = 2/1). The survival rate is better
for Caucasians (54%) than for Afro-Americans (34%). The most common sites
of oral cancer are the floor of the mouth, the sides and undersurface of the
tongue, the back of the throat, and the
lips.
Although it is not considered oral cancer in the strict sense, cancer of the
larynx (the voice box) has a similar etiology (cause & origin) and causes
approximately 2% of all forms of cancer. 90% of the victims of cancer of
the larynx are males, and most are between 60 and 70 years old.
Indications that you may have developed oral or laryngial
cancer
A sore in the mouth that does not heal spontaneously within three weeks;
A lump or thickening in the cheek;
A white or red patch on the gums, tongue, or lining of the mouth;
Soreness or a feeling that something is caught in the throat;
Difficulty chewing or swallowing;
Difficulty moving the jaw or tongue;
Numbness of the tongue or other area of the mouth; or
Swelling of the jaw that causes dentures to fit poorly or become
uncomfortable.
The general characteristics of oral cancer
90%
of all oral cancers are of a type called Squamous cell carcinoma, which
means that they derive from squamous cells which are the type of cells that make
up the pink mucosa that lines the mouth. Laryngeal cancer (cancer of the
vocal cords) is also generally caused by squamous cell carcinoma, and is also
associated with heavy smoking. Most oral cancers tend to happen on the
floor of the mouth or the sides and undersurface of the tongue. They also
tend to be relatively painless
during their early development. The image to
the right shows a rather advanced cancer on the side of the tongue. (Click
the image to see a larger version, as well as some other rather scary examples
of oral cancer.) Note the mottled white and red appearance of the
growth. As you will see, this is an important characteristic of these
cancers.
It is interesting to note that
squamous cell carcinoma is NOTUSUALLY one of the more virulent cancers,
and yet it kills about half of those that get it within 5 years. This is an important
point since
if it is diagnosed at a reasonably early stage (within the first year, or
in some cases within the first two years--The earlier, of course, the better),
it can generally be removed before it becomes locally invasive or spreads to
other parts of the body and becomes a death dealing issue. Why would
anyone let a problem like this progress until it is this large? (Click the
image for more info on why this one got so big.) Why does does such a slow
growing cancer have such a large mortality rate? (Mortality rate is the
measure of the ratio of those who contract the disease to those who die from it.
In the case of Squamous cell carcinoma, the mortality rate is about 50%, meaning
that approximately half the people diagnosed with it will eventually die as a
direct result of the cancer, or from complications associated with it.)
The physical factors that increase the risk of oral cancer
Since 90% of all oral cancers are of a type called Squamous Cell
Carcinoma, when we speak of "risk factors" associated with oral cancer, we
are talking about risk factors associated with this particular entity.
These risk factors do not pertain to the other 10% of cancers which can occur in
the oral cavity. This 10% are covered
later on this page. There are four
factors that appear to increase the risk of developing oral squamous cell
carcinoma:
(1)Tobacco AND (2)alcohol--When indulged in
together over a long period of time, heavy alcohol and tobacco use are the most
potent physical factors contributing to the development of squamous cell carcinoma. Those who both smoke
and drink heavily, have a 15 times greater risk of developing oral cancer
than those that have neither habit.
Tobacco is a known carcinogen, which means that it is known to
damage cellular DNA. Damaged DNA can cause the cellular
reproductive machinery to malfunction, which is the first step in the
growth of malignant cellular masses (cancer).
Alcohol is known to inhibit a gene that functions in response to DNA
damage. This gene is responsible for initiating cell death in
cells in which the the DNA is damaged.
Thus the tobacco causes malignant mutations in the cellular DNA,
while the alcohol inhibits the body's natural defense against
malignancy.
(3)Age--Historically, the large majority of squamous cell carcinoma victims
have, until relatively recently, been
over the age of 40. This probably relates to the tendency of the
immune system to become less and less competent at recognizing and
eliminating mutated cells that arise in the body from time to time. It
may also be associated with the time it takes for the above three factors
discussed in this section to have their damaging effects.
Unfortunately, since about 1975, the cohort with the largest increase of
oral squamous cell cancers has been the age groups under40. This is
due to the"sexual revolution", and the larger number of people contracting
the human papillomavirus (HPV)
(4)HPV--The humanpapilloma virus. HPV is transferred from
person to person by vigorous physical contact, especially oral sexual
contact. A study in the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM), shows
that men and women who reported having six or more oral-sex partners during
their lifetime had a nearly ninefold increased risk of developing cancer of
the tonsils or at the base of the tongue. Of the 300 study participants,
those infected with HPV were also 32 times more likely to develop this type
of oral cancer than those who did not have the virus. It should be noted
that a history of heavy smoking increases the likelihood of contracting
oral-pharyngeal cancers only three times while a history of heavy drinking
increases the likelihood only 2.5 times. HPV is covered in more detail under the lifestyle discussion
below.
Factors relating to
epidemiology and mortality in patients with oral and laryngeal cancers
(Epidemiology is the study of how a disease spreads and who is likely
to get it.)
Lifestyle issues:
Lifestyle issues are behavior patterns which are
considered under the control of the individual. They are the most important factors in the
mortality (death rate) and epidemiology (how the disease spreads, and who is
likely to get sick) associated with oral and laryngeal squamous cell cancers.
Patient lifestyle choices probably accounted for the development of the lesions
seen in the images on this page, and also contributed to the fact that they grew
so large before diagnosis.
Heavy Drinking-- While alcoholis one of
the major physical risk factors in the direct development of oral cancer,
heavy drinking (the behavior) is associated with oral cancer's high mortality (death) rate. Heavy drinkers are much less likely to notice, let alone
seek professional help for a painless growth under their tongues!
Smoking-- Tobaccohas a direct effect on the tissues that the
smoke actually comes into contact with. This includes both the tissues
of the mouth, and the tissues in the larynx (voice box). 75% of
persons who develop oral squamous cell carcinoma are, or have been heavy
smokers. It appears that the effects of tobacco are cumulative, so
people who have been heavy smokers (or snuff dippers) for many years are
more at risk for developing oral or laryngeal cancer than those who have
only recently started.
Smokeless tobacco-- Chewing tobacco and snuff use is
on the rise as the use of cigarettes, cigars and pipes is on the decline.
This is especially true among the young. Since smoking has become
politically incorrect, the use of smokeless tobacco has gained a certain
cachet. Here are some of the facts you should know about smokeless
tobacco:
Smokeless tobacco is a known cause of human cancer; it
increases the risk of developing cancer of the oral cavity and pancreas.
Smokeless tobacco is also strongly associated with
leukoplakia—a
precancerous lesion of the soft tissue in the mouth that consists of a white
patch or plaque that cannot be scraped off.
Smokeless tobacco is associated with recession of the gums,
gum disease, and tooth decay.
Smokeless tobacco use during pregnancy increases the risks
for preeclampsia (i.e., a condition that may include high blood pressure,
fluid retention, and swelling), premature birth, and low birth weight.
Smokeless tobacco use by men causes reduced sperm count and
abnormal sperm cells.
Smokeless tobacco use can lead to nicotine addiction and
dependence.
Adolescents who use smokeless tobacco are more likely to
become cigarette smokers.
Smokeless tobacco is a significant health risk and is not a
safe substitute for smoking cigarettes.
Promiscuous Sexual activity-- When discussing
the human papillomavirus (HPV) as it
relates to oral cancer, the lifestyle issue here relates to sexual behavior. 25% of oral cancers appear in patients who have
never smoked, and it has now been shown that human papillomavirus is the
carcinogenetic element involved in these cases. There are approximately
200 known
strains of the human papillomavirus. Many of the strains of HPV cause
ordinary warts, the kind that develop on the hands and feet, and even in the
oral cavity. Most strains of HPV are thought to be harmless, and
produce no symptoms in the host.
Eighteen strains are associated with cervical cancer but four types
in particular
(in descending order of importance), HPV-16, HPV-18, HPV-31, and
HPV-45, have been shown to be the causative agents of cervical, anal, vulvar
and penile cancers.
(Cervical cancer affects the epithelial cellular layer--the surface
cells--surrounding the opening of the uterus, and vulvar cancer affects the
vaginal opening.) All four are spread by sexual
means. HPV-16 is now known to be implicated as a causative agents in oral squamous cell cancer
in the oropharynx (the mouth and upper throat).
Since the virus itself is transmitted exclusively by vigorous physical
contact, the implication is that oral/genital sexual contact (oral sex) may
be the major means of transmission of the virus.
Five strains of HPV cause
oral papillomas
(warts). These include 6, 7 11, 16 and 32. Note that young
persons who contract oral papillomas, even those infected with HPV-16, will
probably clear the infection eventually if their immune systems are not
adversely affected by other diseases or lifestyle issues like drug or
alcohol addictions.
HPV is the most common sexually transmitted disease in the
United States.
The most alarming statistic about the prevalence of HPV in
most western countries is: "If a college woman has at least one different
sex partner per year for four years, the probability that she will leave
college with an HPV infection is greater than 85%. Condoms do not
protect from the virus because the areas around the genitals including the
inner thigh area are not covered, thus exposing these areas to the infected
person’s skin."
There is no known pharmacological cure for HPV, however, the
human body builds up immune defenses against the virus and in most (but not
all) cases is able to eliminate it from the body eventually. In young,
healthy individuals, the body may clear the infection in a matter of several
months. The exceptions are younger persons with chronic diseases or
addictions to drugs or alcohol.
A 2005 study showed that HPV is associated
with approximately 26% of all head and neck squamous cell carcinomas.
The data linking HPV to mouth and throat cancers is even
stronger, with various published reports showing detection of HPV in 50% or
more of cases.
Normal kissing does
not seem to be implicated, however deep, open mouth (French) kissing may
transmit the virus.
Monogamous couples composed of persons who
have never engaged in sex outside of their relationship are not at risk.
As the incidence of smoking has declined over the last
30 years in the USA, the incidence of promiscuous sexual contact has
risen. Thus the expected benefit of fewer people smoking has been
offset by the liability of more widespread infection with HPV.
This means that the rate of oral cancer diagnosis in the US has remained
constant over the last twenty years, instead of falling as might have
been expected with the decline in the number of smokers.
HPV related oral cancers appear to occur toward the back of
the mouth, that is, in the tonsillar area, the base and sides of the tongue and the oropharynx
(the upper part of the throat), while non-HPV positive tumors
tend to involve the anterior tongue, floor of the mouth, the mucosa that
covers the inside of the cheeks and alveolar ridges (the ridge area in which
the teeth reside).
The problem of HPV is especially acute in the population of
men who have sex with men.
GARDASIL and CERVARIX are vaccines which can immunize a person against
four kinds of HPV, including HPV-16. They currently are being
administered
primarily to young girls and women between the ages of 9 and 26 to prevent
the acquisition the most common forms of HPV which are implicated in causing cervical
cancer. Both vaccines are given in three shots delivered over six
months. They cannot be used to treat active HPV infections or any form
of cancer, even if the cancer was caused by HPV.
There is a saliva test that a dentist can perform that can
diagnose hidden cases of HPV. Dentists interested in offering
this service to their patients can visit the
website of OralDNA
Labs to learn about this simple and accurate process.
For more on the human papilloma virus,
please see the website of the
oral cancer foundation.
Age -- Its relationship to mortality and epidemiology in
oral and laryngeal cancers
The most important factor associated with oral
cancer is
age. Even with the increased incidence of oral cancer in young
persons due to the spread of HPV, the vast majority of persons who develop oral
and laryngeal cancer still tend to be over the age of 40.
95% of oral cancer is diagnosed in people older than 45 years, with the
median age of diagnosis at 64 years. Half of all oral cancers arise in persons over the age of 65.
Advanced
age is probably the most important factor in the mortality associated with the development of
any
cancer. This is due to the fact that as a person ages, his or her immune
system becomes less efficient at recognizing and eliminating aberrant
cellular growths which arise from time to time in people of all ages. Since
about half of all cases of oral cancer, and most cases of laryngeal cancer
occur in patients over the age of 65, the advanced age of this cohort alone
would account for a substantial portion of the mortality rate in these patients.
While HPV is the reason that many more squamous cell
carcinomas are now being found in younger persons, many older people who
have been diagnosed with oral cancers are also infected with HPV. Note
that the prevalence of HPV decreases with age. This may be due to HPV
infection being cleared by the immune system, or sinking to undetectable
levels while still present in the body. Nevertheless, HPV will
probably remain in the infected person's cells for an indefinite time—most
often in a latent state, but occasionally producing symptoms or disease.
In some persons with less competant immune systems, the
virus may remain in an inactive state until and throughout old age.
The factors that are associated with an incompetent immune system are
various chronic disease states as well as drug and alcohol addictions.
This suggests that advancing age, in combination with a long standing HPV
infection (possibly contracted when that person was younger, but more likely
when he or she was older but still sexually active), may place a person at a
far greater risk of contracting squamous cell carcinoma.
The data linking HPV to oropharyngeal cancers is very
strong, with published reports showing detection of HPV in 50% or
more of cases. Based upon this, it is even possible that an HPV
infection contracted in earlier life may place a person at a greater
risk of developing oral cancer as he or she ages than those persons without
the virus, but with the active habits of heavy smoking and drinking.
Painless Lesionscontribute
to the mortality rate ("Lesions" are abnormal growths, erosions or sores.)
The initial lesions of squamous cell carcinoma tend to be
painless. The fact that they are painless makes them easily overlooked
in the early stages. The lack of pain in early lesions combined with the tendency
for this cancer to develop in heavy drinkers may be largely responsible for
oral cancer's 50% 5-year survival rate . These lesions start out as small white
or red patches about 1 to 2 mm in diameter and progress toward larger lesions
slowly. They will usually be noted by a patient when they are large
enough to be felt during movements of the effected organ. They generally appear
to be irregular sores with a white and red mottled center, surrounded by a red border. As the
lesion enlarges, it may become more and more bound-down to the underlying
tissues thus becoming less mobile. Pain and/or numbness generally
develop later in the course of the lesion's growth.
Leukoplakia
Persons
who smoke heavily or use smokeless tobacco such as snuff and chewing tobacco
tend to get whitish patches called leukoplakia on the oral mucosa (the
wet tissue lining the mouth) . The image on the right shows a fairly
typical patch on the side of a man's tongue. The image to the left shows
a similar patch on the floor of the mouth. These patches can happen
anywhere in the oral cavity such as on the cheek
mucosa, the roof of the mouth, or the back of the throat. The common
denominator seems to be HEAVY use of cigarettes or prolonged contact of snuff
or chewing tobacco with cheek tissue. Leukoplakia is not itself a
form of cancer, but is considered pre-cancerous and should be
biopsied (a procedure in which a tiny piece of tissue is sent out for
microscopic examination) since about 20% are found to be pre-malignant . It
is white, firm tissue and cannot be scraped off. It generally goes away
when the stimulation of the tobacco stops, but with continued heavy tobacco
use it can transform into squamous cell cancer. In order to picture what
a cancer developing in these lesions would look like, imagine irregular red
blotches developing inside the white leukoplakic plaque, and a large red
border developing around the entire lesion! Erythroplakia (see
image at right) is the term applied to red bloches which appear within
areas of leukoplakia. Erythroplakia is considered to be more dangerous
than leukoplakia alone. Click on the image to the left or the one to the
imediate right to see these images enlarged, and other scary images of
leukoplakia. Neither leukoplakia nor erythroplakia are contagious
conditions.
The number one cancer of the head and neck is cancer
of the larynx--the voice box--which is more susceptible to particulate
carcinogens such as cigarette smoke and various forms of pollution than
other tissues. The majority of patients who get cancer of the larynx are
men between
60 and 70 years old who have a history of heavy smoking and
generally heavy drinking. Women in the same category are also
prone to squamous cell carcinoma.
Cancer of the lip
Cancers on the lips are a special case. They generally strike the
lower lip and are more likely to happen after long, repeated episodes of
exposure to the sun. Cancer of the lip is also squamous cell
carcinoma and has the same clinical course as intraoral cancers. Going to
the beach several times a summer is generally not a significant risk
factor for cancer on the lip. Most people who get this form of cancer tend
to be outdoor workers who labor all day in the sun for years on end. Perhaps
because more people work indoors today than ever before, the incidence of cancer
of the lip is decreasing.
What about
the other 10% that are not squamous cell carcinoma?
The probability of developing any type of cancer increases with age!
Chronic illness is another factor that increases the likelihood of developing
these forms of cancer. There are, unfortunately, numerous types of cancer that can
originate in various oral structures including bone, lymph nodes, salivary
glands etc. These are not necessarily associated with known risk
factors the way squamous cell cancer is associated with smoking,
drinking and promiscuous oral sexual activity. There is some evidence that non squamous cell cancers of the oral
cavity are related to precipitating factors such as exposure to the Epstein Barr
virus (the virus responsible for mononucleosis which in some persons seems able
to remain dormant in the body for a lifetime) as well as the human papillomavirus (HPV), and radiation treatments to the
head and neck for cancer or acne (not
diagnostic x-rays). Radiation was once a treatment modality for facial acne
(back in the early 20th century) but is no longer used because of the obvious
danger from large amounts of radiation. It is still used in the treatment of
carcinomas and Sarcomas (two different classifications of malignancy) but is carefully aimed and metered to avoid
side effects.
A minorsalivary gland tumor tends to be a firm mass on one side of
the palate (the roof of the mouth). They do not occur in the midline.
If it is cancerous, it will remain enlarged and will not go away after two or
three weeks. About 50% of these large persistent masses will prove to be
malignant (cancer). On the other hand, be aware that small salivary glands in the palatal mucosa do
sometimes become
infected. When this happens, they can become sore and
slightly enlarged, but the problem is generally temporary and disappears without
treatment within two
weeks.
About 80% of all salivary gland tumors begin in the
parotid glands. (A tumor is simply a
mass. It is not necessarily cancerous.) The patient notes a swelling on the side of the face
below and in front of the ear. This swelling does not get larger and
smaller at different times of the day (as salivary gland infections do), but remains constant, or grows larger
over time. 10%-15% of salivary gland tumors start in the submandibular glands
causing a swelling on one side of the neck just under the jawline. These also
remain enlarged over time. The rest develop in the sublingual gland,
causing a similar
swelling under the chin, or in one of the many
minor salivary
glands. Most tumors of the parotids are benign (noncancerous). Masses in
the minor salivary glands (the smallest of salivary glands) are more frequently malignant
(cancerous), however because there are so many more parotid gland tumors, a greater
number of cancers are found in the parotid glands than any of the other salivary
glands. (For a diagram of the major salivary glands, see my page on
Dry Mouth.)
One
of the most deadly forms of oral cancer is Malignant melanoma.
Thankfully, it is very rare in the oral cavity. It begins as small
black spot, generally smaller than a millimeter, and develops irregular
borders as it grows larger (see image on the right). Melanoma can
happen on any tissue in the mouth, particularly inside the lips, cheeks,
undersurface of the tongue and on the hard palate. It is likely to be
tan, dark brown or black, sometimes mixed with red or gray.
Melanoma
occurring anywhere other than the mouth is generally considered to be
fairly treatable. Unfortunately, due to the anatomy of the head and neck,
oral melanoma is most often fatal.
Fortunately,
most dark spots on oral tissue are likely to be
amalgam
tattoos discussed in more depth on the
sores, lumps and bumps
page. Amalgam tattoos happen
after dental appointments, remain stable, do not grow larger over time, and are
relatively circumscribed (without diffuse, irregular borders). They also
tend to have a blue-gray color, unlike the dark brown or black seen in
melanoma. They are most common on the gums, cheeks and floor of mouth
immediately adjacent to teeth. Amalgam tattoos attain and maintain their
maximum size shortly after the introduction of the amalgam into the tissue,
while melanomas will grow and change shape over the course of a week or two.
Although screening by your dentist is the best method of
reducing the pain, suffering and mortality related to oral cancers, it is not
altogether reassuring to know that differentiating early malignant and
premalignant lesions from benign growths is quite difficult, even for
experienced dental practitioners. Early stage oral cancers are
asymptomatic and the clinical characteristics associated with malignancy such as
pain, swelling, redness, enlargement, fixation (becoming bound down to
underlying tissue) and deformation of the surrounding tissues generally do not
develop until quite late in the clinical course of the disease.
Until recently, there were only two courses a dentist could take
when he saw a suspicious early lesion. ("Lesions" are abnormal growths,
erosions or sores.) The first, and most frequent course was waiting
several weeks to see if the lesion progressed or regressed. If It went
away, all was well, and the crisis was averted. If it got bigger, or if
the lesion had been present for several weeks and was already of significant size on initial examination, then the
dentist proceeded to the second course which is a sectional (knife) biopsy
in which the patient is anesthetized and a piece of the lesion is surgically
removed and sent to a laboratory in formalin for microscopic analysis. The
microscopic examination of the tissue sample provides a definitive diagnosis
upon which to base a treatment plan.
The difficulty with this protocol is that there is a high
incidence of oral abnormalities which can be candidates for biopsy. It is
claimed that between 5 and 15% of all new patients present with abnormal lesions
in their mouths, however these include such
lesions as aphthous,
fibromas and
many of the other obviously benign conditions explained on
the Sores, Lumps and Bumps page.
No knowledgeable dentist would consider these to be candidates for biopsy.
Even so, quite a few truly suspicious lesions do walk through our doors with
only about 5% turning out to be cancer. Given these odds, it is
impractical to immediately subject all these lesions to a potentially painful
procedure like a surgical biopsy. Thus, using the older protocol,
virtually everyone presenting with an early lesion was sent home to wait the
obligatory two to three weeks to see if it progressed or not. While not a
dangerous course of action, it still left
any potential malignancy to progress for the entire waiting period plus whatever
time it took to examine the biopsy tissue. It was not especially
reassuring for either the dentist or the patient to know that if there was a
cancerous lesion, it had to wait at least a month to be removed!
A
better screening method has recently become available. It is called
the Brush Biopsy (Oral CDx).This consists of placing a
small, sterile, hard bristled brush over the lesion and twirling it around
until part of surface of the lesion is abraded away. The procedure
rakes up cellular material from the entire thickness of the surface of the
lesion onto the brush. Although this procedure may irritate the area,
(it should produce pinpoint bleeding areas) it does not generally require
local anesthesia. The cellular material scraped up on the brush is
smeared onto a glass slide, fixed with a chemical that comes with the kit,
and dried. The glass slide is then placed into a plastic container and
sent to a lab for computer scanning and further manual examination of
suspicious cells. The makers of this biopsy kit claim 100% accuracy in
identification of abnormal cellular components provided that the clinician
was aggressive enough in obtaining a full thickness sample. The brush
biopsy does NOT establish a definitive diagnosis. It does indicate the
need for a surgical biopsy to establish the diagnosis.
It should be noted that not all experts on oral cancer believe that
cytological examination alone is suitable as a screening device for oral
squamous cell carcinoma. The brush biopsy is not suitable for melanoma ( pigmented lesions) or
lesions on the dry parts of the lips. It is generally reserved for
use on lesions that show eroded or overgrown mucosal surfaces. Its
principle use is for pre-cancerous lesions that will develop into
squamous cell carcinoma. It is not useful for deeper lesions such
salivary gland tumors.
Zila Pharmaceuticals has heavily marketed a light source
which, when shined on oral mucosa is reputed to cause squamous cell
carcinoma lesions to fluoresce, thus helping a trained clinician to spot
them for early detection of oral cancer. This product is called
Vizilite, and it is heavily marketed to dentists. It would be a great
benefit for the early detection of oral cancer if......it actually worked as
advertised.
In 2004, "the manufacturers of Vizilite applied to the ADA for the ADA
Seal of Acceptance for their product. The official seal of
acceptance is considered the ultimate in product recognition
in terms of marketing a given product for use in dentistry
in the United States. The Council on Scientific Affairs is
charged with the review of all studies related to products
requesting the seal. The companies are asked to submit all
studies that support their claims. They are required to
submit at least two credible clinical studies.
The usual requirement is that of two independent double
blind clinical trials, each conducted at a separate site.
In addition to the review of this data by the entire Council
on Scientific Affairs, the studies are sent out to a number
of outside reviewers. The conclusion on Vizilite was quite
clear. Their submitted study data was extremely weak. All
outside consultants were in agreement in not supporting the
product for the seal. The Council was unanimous in not
supporting the application." (Click
here for the reference)
This light source has apparently been shown
to be beneficial in the differentiation of cervical (uterine) squamous cell
carcinoma. It appears, however, that the progression of the same
cancer in the oral cavity is biologically different from the progression of
cervical squamous cell carcinoma, and for this reason, it is of limited use
in the oral cavity.
Therefore, the use of the Vizilite as a method of screening for oral
cancer is probably more of an unnecessary expense than a benefit to either
patients or the doctors using it.
Even so, the manufacturers of Vizilite
continue to heavily market the product, and even advertise in the Journal of
the American Dental Association. The presence of an ad in the Journal
does not mean that the ADA endorses the product, any more than an ad on this
website means that I endorse the product.
If you have come here to look for
images of lumps, bumps, sores or discolorations that you noticed in the
mirror this morning, this is one of four pages with images you may find
useful. Read this page,
Then proceed to three other pages on which you will find more images
of both normal and abnormal oral structures and lesions
All material on this web site is protected by copyright and is registered with
the US Copyright office. All personal uses, including public and
academic presentations, are
permitted. This fair use
permission applies to oral and written reports, dissertations and theses for
students in public and private schools, elementary and high schools, colleges
and graduate schools. It also applies to teachers wishing to print this
material for classroom and course work. Acknowledgement of this website as
the source for this material during presentations is not required, but would be
appreciated. Any dentist or other professional who finds this material
useful is welcome to print and distribute it to patients, or to refer their
patients to this website.
Written requests for publication on the internet or other mass media (including
printed publications) will be considered on a case-by-case basis. Internet
and printed publication IS permitted (without permission, but with attribution)
if it is part of a qualified academic dissertation, but any other
internet or mass media use of this material without written permission is
STRICTLY prohibited. Requests for such usage may be forwarded to me
using the email button in the right shared border.
If permission is granted, you must credit me for the
use of the material and link to this website prominently from your own.
Dentists and web developers who cut and paste content and/or images from
doctorspiller.com into their own websites and claim them as their own are
forewarned that this may result in legal action.
Web developers may NOT
copy the content or images from this website for use
in developing commercial websites for other dentists or health care providers.
This activity is strictly illegal! Copyright law provides that owners of
registered copyrighted material may sue for monetary damages.
This website is registered with the US Copyright office in its entirety
(Certificate of Registration:
TX0006443750),
and copies are regularly updated and maintained at the Library of Congress. Click here for
more information concerning the copyright on this material.
DISCLAIMER: Statements made on this web site
are for informational purposes only and are not intended to be substituted for
the advice of a medical professional. Information and statements
have not been evaluated by the American Dental Association or any federal
regulation agency and are not intended to diagnose, or treat any disease or
medical condition. This is a personal website written by an individual
dental professional whose intention is to enlighten the public with generally
accepted, mainstream medical/dental information. I do not claim to
represent the opinions of all dental or medical professionals. No website is a
substitute for a visit to a living, breathing dentist or physician who can deal
with you personally.